The Personalization Puzzle: Assembling the Pieces of Connected Commerce Experiences

Carl Bleich
Carl Bleich

At Bloomreach, we believe that the best way to achieve personalization success is by thinking of it like a puzzle. 

Each puzzle piece is essential to a complete picture, but it must be assembled correctly to see its true value. Even if you have all the right pieces, if you arrange them into an image that doesn’t make sense, then you won’t see the results you were hoping for. 

Ecommerce personalization is additive in nature. You’re always adding pieces to something that already exists. You’re not ascending a magical ladder where you can forget what’s on the lower rungs. Each step of the customer experience matters and will always matter.

Personalization is also complex and composed of many individual pieces, but what’s ultimately most important is how the pieces connect to build out the bigger picture. 

Personalization can be the unifying force behind your digital commerce team or it can be the wedge that drives the team apart. Unlocking commerce growth with ecommerce personalization has never been more important, especially as the top and fastest-growing companies strive to make true personalization a reality.   

There are nine distinct pieces of the personalization puzzle. Let’s explore each of them in more detail, including actionable advice on where to start improving your customer experience and growing digital revenue.

Baseline Experience

You have to start somewhere, right? 

Baseline experience is what anonymous visitors get with your company. What role does it play in the personalization puzzle? Well, first-time visitors you know nothing or little about are often your largest customer segment. And you need to make sure they enjoy a great, frictionless experience on your website, with your app, and with all of your other customer touchpoints. 

Improvement tactics: 

  • A/B testing

  • Cart optimization 

  • Page speed optimization 

Key metrics: 

  • New visit conversion rate

  • Cart completion rate

Customer Analytics

Analyzing customer behavior is one of the basic principles of personalization.  

In order to provide any level of personalization, you need to understand what your customers are doing, what their preferences are, and other contextual information. In order to do that, you also need commerce data (a combination of customer and product data) and integrations between systems that generate it.

Improvement tactics: 

Key metrics: 

  • Speed to reporting

  • Speed to insight

Cross-channel Orchestration 

The power to orchestrate campaigns across different channels is essential to effective ecommerce personalization. 

The more channels you add to your marketing mix, the more effective your personalized campaigns can be. Reach people on the most relevant channels based on context and their preferences.

Improvement tactics: 

  • Adding new channels

  • Ideal send time

  • Cross-channel teams

Key metrics: 

  • In-channel management

  • Results at the customer level

Content Management

Content is everything on your website that isn’t a product. And that encompasses a lot. 

To have any chance at effective personalization, you need to have different variants of your content for your different customer segments. You also need a library of content assets to pull from when building a personalized experience. Getting that right is a big piece of the personalization puzzle.

Improvement tactics: 

  • Increase sales by creating bespoke content for various customer segments

  • Ensure a consistent brand message and reuse the same content across channels (web, app, etc.)

  • Inspire your customers to buy with media-rich stories

Key metrics: 

  • Cart abandonment

  • Engagement rate

  • Customer lifetime value

  • Speed to build and change a page

  • Content engagement (page views, time spent on page, etc.)


Search is how your customers find their way to enticing products. 

But the way customers talk about products changes every day, and what customers find most relevant to their search is never alike. That’s why you need search to be powered by an in-depth understanding of commerce data. With commerce data feeding into AI-driven search, you can produce search results that feel effortlessly personal to your customers.

Improvement tactics: 

  • Automatically correct customer searches by adding spell check, autosuggest, and synonyms for common searches

  • Remove dead ends by providing relevant or related results on null/zero result searches

Key metrics: 

  • Revenue from search

  • Number of null search results

  • Average order size

Product Recommendations

Customers rely on you to help them navigate the many products you have to offer. 

That’s why it’s imperative that you showcase how products relate to each other, just like a sales associate in a store might recommend a great tie to go with that shirt. What products are in stock? Which are similar? What is the newest model? Answering many more questions like these can help you recommend products and categories based on customer behaviors or preferences.

Improvement tactics: 

  • Add bestsellers and trending products to your home page, and use AI  to always keep them up to date

  • Feature categories like new arrivals, brand collections, or aisle shopping to keep repeat customers engaged

  • Connect categories by showing related categories and products within a category page

  • Help repeat customers reorder by showing their past purchases

  • Show what other customers also bought on the add-to-cart page for one final effort to increase their order size

Key metrics: 

  • Cross-sell and upsell conversions

  • Average order value/basket size

Product Grids

Product grids are a key way for you to curate your catalog for your customers. 

Which products should be shown first in each search? Which should be first within a category? By refining the experience through boost/bury rules, you can shape exactly how the product grid appears and highlight new products, promote a popular brand, or even feature high-margin items.

Improvement tactics: 

  • Boost or bury products within the grid according to your business goals

  • Add recommendations to category or search results pages to give products special attention, such as your highest-margin SKUs or bestsellers 

Key metrics: 

Cross-channel Experiences

Think about the consistency of experiences customers have with your brand on your owned touchpoints (e.g., website, app, or emails). Is that experience consistent? 

Do they see the same products? Do the touchpoints feel the same? More importantly, are your customers able to continue where they left off after switching channels? Consistent experiences lead to more conversions and happier customers.

Improvement tactics: 

  • Save cart items and restore them later on with a persistent cart that can be accessed by logged-in customers 

  • Share a common data platform for all channels

  • Make an effort to consistently personalize experiences across channels with a headless experience manager

Key metrics: 

  • Revenue per visitor (RPV)

  • Percentage of identified sessions

  • Cross-channel conversion rate

  • Customer satisfaction or NPS

Cross-channel Campaigns

Just like experiences, your campaigns should also be consistent across channels. 

Once customers make a purchase, they shouldn’t see remarketing ads for that same product. When they see a promotion in an email or via push notifications, they should be able to find that promotion on your website as well. Customers shouldn’t be blasted by all the campaigns, but rather only those that are most appropriate for them. At the highest level, this requires knowing which customers are likely to respond to which campaigns in all of your marketing channels in real time.

And of course, your campaigns must respect customer privacy at all times

Improvement tactics: 

Key metrics: 

  • Number of customer support requests for a post-purchase discount after seeing a campaign

  • Frequency of communications per customer

  • Bounce rate from campaigns

Piece Together Your Personalization Puzzle With Bloomreach

Your company’s primary goal in piecing together a personalization puzzle should be to facilitate joyous customer experiences that inspire your consumers to be loyal to your brand. This will ultimately lead to the growth of your digital business. 

You may not have all the pieces right now, and that’s okay! Don’t feel like you need to build your personalization puzzle all at once — it takes time and effort to put it all together.

If you’re looking for more information about how to identify which pieces of the personalization puzzle are missing for your company, watch our “Missing Piece of Personalization” webinar on demand. Together with our partners Ansira and Sinch, our industry experts discussed the real-life examples and results from companies that have successfully assembled their personalization puzzles and provided connected commerce experiences to their customers. 

You can also learn more about the importance of using ecommerce personalization to facilitate connected commerce experiences. Or better yet, schedule a personalized demo to see it in action.



Carl Bleich

Head of Content at Bloomreach

Carl works with Bloomreach professionals to produce valuable, customer-centric content. A trusted expert with over 15 years of experience, Carl loves exploring unique ways to turn problems into solutions within digital commerce. Read more from Carl here.

Table of Contents

Share with Your Community

Recent Posts

Maintain an Edge With These New Posts


Subscribe to get our hot takes on ecommerce topics, trends and innovations delivered to straight your inbox.

Life With Bloomreach

Watch this video to learn what your life could look like when you use Bloomreach.